We welcome you to Christ’s Church, Rye, a diverse, dynamic and devoted community of faith that has gathered strength from its early beginning, perseverance with challenges and inspiration from its leadership and ministries over 300 years.
Established in 1695 to comply with a law requiring a “church” in Rye, the parish’s first service was held in 1702, with a stone building known as Grace Church completed in 1706. Making that his mission, Colonel Caleb Heathcote, Senior Warden, then founded a school there for some Native Americans, while searching for a suitable rector. The Rev. George Muirson became the first permanent rector of among thirty to follow. Muirson and Heathcote made several visits to surrounding areas (Bedford, NY; Stamford and Stratford, CT), encouraging new missions for the Anglican church. The first communion ware, a chalice and paten presented in 1706 to the parish by Queen Anne at Heathcote’s urging, is still used today, a gift reflecting the church’s rich history and adherence to tradition amidst change. Shortly after the Rev. James Wetmore (1726-1760) retired, a Royal Charter was granted to the parish in 1764 by King George 111, formalizing the relationship with the Church of England.
A decade later, the American Revolution divided Rye, testing loyalties and the required adherence of clergy to the British Crown. The church’s rector, the Rev. Ephraim Avery, seen as a Tory sympathizer, did not survive, found near the church with his throat cut in 1776. Nor did the church building, later burned. In 1788 a new church (the second of what would be four in the same location) was built and Episcopal congregation reorganized in 1796 as Christ’s Church. With an official seal presented to the parish by Peter Jay, the church experienced renewal and a period of modest growth under the rectorship of the Rev. Samuel Haskell (1797-1801 and 1809-1823).
The need for additional clergy to serve a larger congregation may have influenced the move of the existing church across the street, replaced by the construction, in 1855, of a stone, Gothic style third church with a steeple and Sunday School (1865). The present church, similar in its exterior, was built 11 years later, then consecrated in 1869, following the destruction of its predecessor in a fire. Architectural additions included a Rectory (1878), a chapel and bell turret (1893), a new altar, reredos and Tiffany chancel window (1896), a parish house (1923), Chapel of Thanksgiving (1952) and Sunday School/office wing (1957). Of special significance was the parish’s first vested choir beginning in 1890.
Endurance, patience, recognition, commemoration, celebration, generosity and gratitude marked these years. The church and choir observed their notable anniversaries, women’s eligibility to vote and be Vestry members, the war time service of clergy and members, the ordination of women and their ministries with the parish.
In 2000, the Rev. Canon Susan Harriss became the first female rector of Christ’s Church. Her singular leadership revitalized the congregation and deepened its spirituality, preparing Christ’s Church for its sacred ministries and vibrant work in the future. Canon Harriss retired in September of 2016, becoming Rector Emerita.
Christ's Church welcomed its 31st Rector, the Rev. Kate Malin in March of 2018. Kate's Institution was held on Thursday evening, June 14th. It was a joyful and jubilant celebration of the beginning of an exciting new chapter in the lengthy life of Christ's Church Rye. The future is writ large! To learn more about Kate, her family and this next chapter in Christ's Church history, please click here.
A very special thank you to writer and historian, Betsy Field, for composing the Christ's Church History page.